โฐ All orders need at least 48 hours' notice ยท Cash only (Venmo coming soon!)

Handcrafted Cookies,
Baked with Love

Fresh from Nancy's home kitchen: classic chip cookies by the dozen and beautifully decorated sugar cookies.

Order Now See the Menu

How Ordering Works

Three easy steps to warm, fresh cookies.

1

Pick Your Cookies

Use the + and โˆ’ buttons on the menu to choose your favorites. Your order summary updates as you go.

2

Choose a Time

Pick pickup or delivery and a date at least 48 hours out. Pickup is Wed & Fri 4โ€“6 PM or Sat 12โ€“4 PM.

3

Confirm & Enjoy

Nancy will email or call to confirm. Pay cash at pickup or delivery, then enjoy!

Please order at least 48 hours in advanceEvery cookie is baked fresh for your order, so we need two full days' notice.

๐Ÿ•“ Pickup Windows

Wednesday: 4โ€“6 PM
Friday: 4โ€“6 PM
Saturday: 12โ€“4 PM

Pickup location is shared when your order is confirmed.

๐Ÿš— Delivery

Delivery is available on request. Details and any fee will be confirmed with you after you order.

๐Ÿ’ต Payment

Cash only for now.
Venmo is coming soon!

Place Your Order

Add cookies from the menu above, then fill out the form below.

๐Ÿš— Delivery details and any fee will be confirmed with you after you place your order. Please include your address in the notes.

At least 48 hours from now. Pickup on Wed, Fri, or Sat.

Cash only at pickup/delivery ยท Venmo coming soon

A cozy home kitchen counter with a tray of fresh chocolate chip cookies, a mixing bowl with a wooden spoon, and a pink apron hanging nearby

Meet Nancy

Nummy Nancy's is a little cookie business run by a young baker with big dreams: serving her community, learning how a business works, saving up for hockey gear, and one day opening a real bakery.

Made in a home kitchen that also processes wheat, dairy, eggs, and nuts.

Read Nancy's Story

Frequently Asked Questions

Got a question? Here are the most common ones.

How far in advance do I need to order?

At least 48 hours. Every order is baked fresh, so the form only allows dates two or more days out. For large orders or events, more notice is appreciated.

When can I pick up my order?

Wednesday and Friday from 4โ€“6 PM, and Saturday from 12โ€“4 PM. The pickup location is shared when your order is confirmed.

Do you deliver?

Yes, delivery is available on request. Choose "Delivery" on the order form and add your address in the notes. Nancy will confirm the details and any fee with you.

How do I pay?

Cash only for now, paid at pickup or delivery. Venmo is coming soon!

How should I store my cookies?

Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 5 days. You can freeze chip cookies for up to 3 months; thaw at room temperature. Decorated sugar cookies are best kept at room temperature, not refrigerated, to protect the icing.